13 Comments

  1. Great compilation of information, saving me a lot of time to research. Have gone ahead to register for Elastiq and Singlife with your referral codes (already maxed out on Singtel Dash before I came across your article).

    However, might want to indicate that the Singlife interest is non-guaranteed. Might influence the decision for some people.

    • Thank you Justin for the kind comments and feedback.

      I have included an extra note for the non-guaranteed interest for Singlife Account, so as to avoid any misunderstandings. Thanks again and have a great evening!

  2. Hey IQ, thank you so much for the compilation.

    I wonder if you have considered Unit Trusts that buys into short term bonds that pay out dividends. Granted, it will not be as liquid as those options that you have mentioned. But I thought if one can stretch the withdrawal time slightly to say up to 10 working days (aka 2 weeks) but be given a relatively higher interest in returns in the form of dividends.

    some products I have came across including Eastsping’s Investment Funds – Monthly Income Plan (thru FSM One giving up to 5% p.a.) or Silverdale Bond Fund (thru Kristal AI giving up to 8% p.a. for the past three years).

    Of course, there is no guaranteed dividend yield just like none of the above (less the endowment funds) give you guarenteed interest given that they can adjust the expected interest with advance notice at any point in time.

    I might be wrong. Do share with me what do you think? (:

    • Hi Jason,

      Thank you for the question!

      If you have a longer-term horizon, you probably won’t want to be putting all your savings in the Insurance Savings Plans / Cash Management Accounts mentioned in this article, which have very low level of risk (commensurate with the relatively low but sometimes guaranteed returns). So it is right for you to be looking at higher returning assets for the savings in excess of your emergency needs.

      For the two funds you mentioned, the risk is quite a bit higher.

      1) Eastspring Monthly Income Plan
      – Current exposure is around 30% Investment Grade Bonds (BBB rated or better), 6% in stocks and the remaining ~60% in High Yield Bonds (BB rated or below).
      – For bonds, your long-term returns will be capped to the bond portfolio’s yield to maturity, which is more or less translated to the 5% income you will be getting.
      – However, you do need to take into account the risk of principal loss due to bond defaults (which will permanently pull down the fund’s NAV), especially with the such a large proportion of the fund invested in High Yield Bonds.
      – On average, High Yield Bond default rates across an economic cycle is 3-4% per year, of which you will likely be able to recover 40% of a defaulted bond’s value. This means you have to factor in at least (60% High Yield Bond exposure * 4% default rate * 60% default loss = 1.4% expected principal losses per year) for the High Yield component of this fund.
      – So it is prudent to adjust down your return expectations lower than the 5% yield that the fund is giving, perhaps to a 3-3.5% per annum range from this point on.
      – For context on the level of risk for the fund, the peak to trough NAV pullback in Feb-Mar this year was -18% (it has recovered about 2/3 of this decline since).

      2) Silverdale Bond Fund
      – Exposure is approx 70% Investment Grade and 30% High Yield.
      – They generate slightly higher yields because half the bonds are from China and Indian companies.
      – Also note that the gross yield to maturity of the fund is now 4.67% (or 4.17% net after you deduct off the fund’s 0.5% management fee).
      – So you might consider managing down your annual return expectations to perhaps: 4.17% minus the expected annual bond default losses.
      – For context on the level of risk for the fund, the peak to trough NAV pullback in Feb-Mar this year was -29% (it has recovered about 60% of this decline since).

      The Etiqa ELASTIQ does guarantee a 1.8% per annum interest for the first 3 years, and can be surrendered during this time with no penalty (i.e. you still get to keep the interest that has been accrued). So I think it’s a pretty good trade-off.

      Hope this helps!

  3. Hi, I dropped a note in your Gigantic article and not sure if it was appropriate for you to comment there. As I wrote, I managed to open an Elastiq account earlier and have $100k in there. I have an additional $50k; it seems to make more sense to just top up Elastiq account rather than use any of these other options; given that I will receive 1.8% PA for it. The only downside I see is that above $100k, I will no longer be covered under SDIC. Did I miss out anything?

    • Hi K,

      I too have an Etiqa ELASTIQ account. It was a good deal.

      From my understanding, only the initial premium’s 1.8% p.a. interest is guaranteed. The interest rate for top ups is based on the prevailing market conditions, which is up to Etiqa’s discretion. I have extracted the relevant part of the policy’s provisions below for reference (last sentence is most relevant):

      “For the initial single premium, the crediting rate for the first 3 years from the Policy commencement date is guaranteed and fixed at the crediting rate determined by us on the Policy commencement date. You may refer to the Policy Illustration for the guaranteed crediting rates for the first 3 years from the Policy issue date. For subsequent years, the crediting rate will be determined by us based on the prevailing rate, subject to the minimum guaranteed crediting rate of 0% p.a. which ensures that your capital is fully guaranteed each year.

      For any Top-up(s) made, the crediting rate will be determined by us based on prevailing market conditions. We reserve the right to revise the crediting rate for Top-up(s) from time to time.”

      So, while it’s a hassle to create a new GIGANTIQ or Singlife account, at least you have better assurance of the rates you will be getting.

  4. Thanks you for your reply. Does this mean if the top up rate at the moment is 1.8% and I top up $50k; the interest rate for this $50k will not be 1.8% for the entire period. (3 years based on the first initial deposit).

    Is this what you understand?

1 Trackback / Pingback

  1. Phillip SGD Money Market ETF: Is it worth investing in? - The InvestQuest

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*